The Evolvement of the Practice of Korbanot – One Reason for the Survival of Judaism

 

 

                                                   “Judaism is an ongoing moral revolution.” –                                                                                                                      Rabbi  Jonathan Sack ZT”L

This week’s Parashah, Tzav, addresses the subject of Korbanot (sacrifices), an important service, first performed in the Mishkan (Tabernacle) in the desert and later in Beit Hamikdash (Holy Temple) in Yerushalayim. The term korbanot is derived from the root K,R,B which means to draw closer. The purpose of the Korban was to bring people closer to G-d.

As I mentioned in an article that I wrote several weeks ago, sacrifices were a means to gain Teshuvah (repentance). As I also stressed there, animal sacrifices or the blood sprinkled on the altar were not then, before and after the existence of either the Tabernacle or the Temple, the only means to reach atonement or becoming one with G-d.                                           (https://wingnsonawildflight.blogspot.com/2022/02/the-currency-of-teshuvah.html)

The ritual of animal sacrifices, just like some of our other tenets, is not a Jewish one by origin. These practices were prevalent in the pagan societies of the ancient near eastern world, the world in which our forefathers resided and reared and were, as a result, steeped in them. In those societies, human sacrifices were part of the practice.

Why, then, one may ask, did we adopt it and why does the sacrificial system make up such a large part of our Torah?

       In his book, Guide for the Perplexed, Ramba”m explains that the Torah’s main purpose for including the ritual of sacrifices was to expunge the notion of paganism. According to him, the Torah instituted this system to help wane idolatrous practices. He further claims that human nature dictates that customs practiced over time become ingrained in them and cannot be easily  uprooted (3:30,3:32).

      Naturally, as Ramba”m suggests, the transition from one extreme to another, the disposing of old and well rooted customs that, over time, become part of human nature, cannot occur over night. The course needs time to acclimate. However, when we delve into the details of the practice as presented to Am Yisrael, in the Torah, we will discover the fascinating transformation of that pagan habit into what can be considered a brilliant move towards individual enrichment and the continued survival of a nascent nation.

Whereas in their surrounding antiquated cultures, such as in Egypt, where the hieroglyphics and the secrets of temple rituals, including the sacrificial ones, were under the exclusive authority of the priestly class, performed by them and known to them only, in the Torah, according to Professor Yonatan Grossman, the sacrificial directives in this Parashah are meant for the People as a whole. In his book, Torat Ha’Korbanot (The Torah of Sacrifices), Grossman claims that each Yisraelite who wishes to offer the sacrifice is the owner of the sacrifice and the Priest is merely their messenger. This message is resonated in the early verses of Viykra (Leviticus). It addresses every individual among Bnei Yisrael, “Speak to the Yisraelites and say to them: ‘When anyone among you brings an offering to the Lord, bring as your offering an animal from either the herd or the flock” (1:2). This verse, suggests Grossman, is to reveal to all members of Am Yisrael the secrets of the Mishkan and its practices. Its aim, he believes, is to induce the Divine Spirit among the People to attain and implement the sense of partnership between Man and G-d.

Considering the sacrificial practices that were prevalent in the region in those days, according to Grossman, this directive was revolutionary. It is not another esoteric secret literature like the ones that existed in the surrounding cultures. Rather, he asserts, it was a public one which should be shared with each member of Am Yisrael.

It is this kind of an ongoing evolution, adaptation to new realities, and the introduction of new concepts that have prevented Judaism from becoming extinct, according to Rabbi Sacks. In his essay entitled “Why Civilizations Die,” Sacks refers to Rebecca Costa’s Book, The Watchman’s Rattle, which provides her account of how civilizations like the Mayan or the Khmre die. “Societies,” writes Sacks, “reach what she calls a cognitive threshold. They simply can’t chart a path from the present to the future.”

Costa believes that it can happen to any civilization. The breakdown, she asserts, is identifiable through two signs. The first is gridlock where instead of dealing with clearly recognized problems, “these problems are passed to the next generation.” The second one is the retreat into irrationality. Religious consolation replaces their inability to cope with facts. “Archeologists,” Sacks recounts, “have uncovered gruesome evidence of human sacrifice on a vast scale….” of the Mayans and Khmre civilizations whose members sought such consolation and “focused on placating gods by manically making offerings to them.”

Despite facing two centuries of Roman oppression, the destruction of the Temple which brought about the cessation of the practice of sacrifices, Jewish sages did not focus on how to atone without sacrifice. Instead, they focused on finding substitutes for sacrifice. These included engaging in good deeds, studying Torah and prayer.

Judaism is indeed an “ongoing moral revolution,” as Sacks suggests. Though we have not obsessively clung on to our past, we have not forgotten nor abandoned it. We followed it while “thinking through the future,” by revolutionizing ancient concepts for the purpose of adjusting, surviving, and eventually also thriving in new and unfamiliar terrain.

Am Yisrael Chai

The Currency of Teshuvah

 

The purpose of this article, as most of my articles, is mainly to share knowledge. I wish to help my fellow Jews connect with, learn and become more educated about our great Jewish tradition and heritage. Knowledge about the  subject discussed and highlighted  in this article is power and ignorance of it is anything but a bliss.

This week’s Parashah addresses, among other issues, the subject of “Kofer.” The term, in its different variations, “Kapparah,” “Kapper,” “Kippurim,” is discussed in chapter 30 verses 12-16.

Literally, the root “K,F,R” in Hebrew means payment for the purpose of deliverance from a predicament or trouble. It is also the root of  “deny, contradict and repudiate." Loosely rendered into English, the word also means, “repentance” or “atonement,” in the theological context.

“Repentance” originates from the Latin poenitire (with the added prefix re-), meaning “make sorry.” “Atonement” signifies to be "at one” with or to reconcile with others. Both terms are the underlying principle of Christianity. They are also an important part of Judaism. However, in both faiths they carry an entirely different meaning and the processes or practices towards achieving that stage are dissimilar .                                                                                                                                                                      

Those of you who know me, are already aware that I shy away from renditions of Biblical Hebrew Jewish terms into other languages (which are often grossly mistranslated, unfortunately, as I have shown on more than one occasion). Therefore, to avoid any confusion, or misunderstanding when discussing the subject of “Kofer,” I will use the Hebrew term “teshuvah.”

The term “teshuvah” is derived from the Hebrew root “to return.” It implies returning to G-d, or as Rabbi Sacks, ZT”L succinctly explains it, a state of reconciliation between “G-d’s high hopes for humanity with our shabby and threadbare moral record.” Ramba”m, who wrote extensively on the subject of “Teshuvah,” (The Laws of Teshuvah) movingly describes the effects of this metamorphic experience whereby a person who “yesterday was distant from G-d …today clings to G-d.” Teshuvah is about regret, admission of wrongdoing and the relinquishment of sin. The eventual goal of Teshuvah is to attain G-d’s forgiveness.

One of the essential elements of the process of Teshuvah and being forgiven by G-d was the practice of animal sacrifices and sprinkling their blood, initially, on the altar of the Tabernacle and later in the Temple. According to Ramba”m, (A Guide to the Perplexed part 3, 32) the mitzvot addressing animal sacrifices were meant to wean Am Yisrael from the idolatry rites that existed in the ancient world. These practices were entrenched in the societies and the peoples among whom they resided. Ramba”m claims that one cannot expect a human being to cease certain behaviours abruptly without preparing alternative ones for them. G-d did not want to transform Man’s nature in a miraculous way. He rather wanted him to change his character gradually, along, and in harmony with the course of nature. Hence G-d allowed Am Yisrael to continue that specific ritual while channeling it towards serving Him, whose wisdom is above all, in place of offering these sacrifices to human made or even imaginary entities devoid of any substance.   

Following the destruction of the Temple and the cessation of the practice of animal sacrifices, our sages established three ways to replace them. They are, Torah, Avordah (literally ”work” or “service”) and Gemilut Chassadim (kindness and charity), the “three pillars upon which the world stands.”  These, they decreed, can help us reach the goal of being at one with G-d (Ethics of The Fathers, 1:2).

Torah: The Talmud tells us that one who delves into and studies the laws of sacrifices, it is as though he has essentially offered them. 

Avodah: Replacing the sacrificial “service of G-d” with prayer which verbally articulates our devotion to G-d. In the words of Hosea, “We will render the prayers of our lips in place of sacrifices of bullocks,” (Hosea, 14:3). Other sources in the Tanach stress that sincere Teshuvah through prayer and fast is all that G-d demands. In the Book of Jonah, for instance, the people of Nineveh had sinned and were going to before they were punished by G-d. Following Jonah’s warning, they fasted and prayed. G-d, eventually, forgave them and their devastation was averted. Another example of how Avodah can foil the plans of the worst of our enemies is provided in the Book of Esther.

Gemilut Chassadim: Giving Charity or engaging in acts of self-sacrifice are also considered part of doing Teshuvah. Giving one’s hard-earned money to charity is a form of giving of oneself for the greater good. Giving money which one could have spent for personal use or benefit is, in a way, the ultimate form of sacrifice.

This brings us back to the section that discusses “Kippurim” in this week’s Parashah. G-d instructs Moshe to collect money from Am Yisrael, “When you take the sum of the Children of Yisrael according to their numbers, let each one give to the Lord a Koffer for his soul…. And there will be no plague among them when they are counted…..This they give half a shekel shall be an offering to  the Lord…. To Kapper for your souls. You shall take the silver of the Kippurim from the Children of Yisrael and use it for the work of the Tent of the Meeting: it shall be a remembrance for the Children of Yisrael before the Lord to “Kapper” for your souls.” 

Needless to remind the readers that these directives were given to Moshe BEFORE the Temple or even the Tabernacle were constructed and BEFORE animal sacrifices or blood offering could be performed as part of Teshuvah (or repentance, as some refer to it).

The practice of the currency of Teshuvah continues to be used regularly as part of seeking forgiveness by G-d. As a matter of fact, yours truly has been performing it since an early age, and still does, each year on the Eve of Yom Kippur. I do it with a sincere hope that my transgressions, albeit unintentional, against G-d and my fellow men and women are forgiven.

Shabbat Shalom and every blessing